Review Policy

If you’d like to request a review, please email me: edmcwatt@gmail.com

I am keeping my reviewing narrowly focused on the Young Adult and Historical Fiction genres – the ideal submission would combine both!

I only review books that I’ve purchased, borrowed or have been given as a review copy. I don’t accept payment for reviews. Paper copies preferred but electronic accepted.

I’ll keep my criticism confined to the book and my perception of its strengths or flaws. No ad hominem here.

My ratings are as follows:

star_rating_5_of_5

5 stars – you are the next Joseph Heller

star_rating_4_of_5

4 stars – really enjoyed it, highly recommended

star_rating_3_of_5

3 stars Рnot without merit, failed to light any fires in me though

star_rating_2_of_5

2 stars – flawed/ bored

star_rating_1_of_5

1 star – you are the next Zoe Heller, IMHO